Ecology and Society Ecology and Society
E&S Home > Vol. 19, Iss. 2 > Art. 19 > Discuss Open Access Publishing 


The notion of sewage as waste: a study of infrastructure change and institutional inertia in Buenos Aires, Argentina and Vancouver, Canada. 2014. Öberg, G., M. G. Merlinsky, A. LaValle, M. Morales and M. M. Tobias

  • Discussion (1 comments)
  • Register

In search of a new way out
Horacio Feinstein on Oct 24, 2015 13:04:22

 Reading the title of the paper, I imagined  an interesting comparison between cities, both  on water-fronts but quite different as to ecological awareness of the population (Vancouver, with high awareness; Buenos Aires, with low awareness).


Reading the paper I noticed, with surprise, great similarities between both cities on the matter, while the abovementioned differences are so wide. It would be interesting to find out about this assymetry.  My intuition leads me to infer that our contemporary  universal life-style and capitalistic system has much to do with it.


About the fruitful  insight of possible changes on the future of Buenos Aires sewage management and of the reutilization of resources within  the excrements of city inhabitants  because of energy scarcity,  I see an interesting scenario for change. With reference to this, I want to point out  to what happened at the end of year 2013. During huge and long black-outs in Buenos Aires City thousands of old and handicapped  people living in high buildings were trapped up in their apartment without elevator, electricity, water and sanitary facilities.  Against city mayor response (“we’ll buy and install hundreds of gasoline-run electrical generators for each of  those buildings”) originated a proposal from people´s assemblies to start a Green Plan involving one million new trees for the city streets, considering -besides other benefits- that the cooling effect of one tree is equivalent to one medium home air conditioner; and  as for water pumping, photovoltaic pumps would be of great interest.



Ecology and Society. ISSN: 1708-3087